Repair or replace your boiler?

An honest way to decide whether a broken boiler is worth fixing, from engineers who make money either way.

Boilers · · By the Green PHS team

Engineer testing the circuit board of a boiler

When a boiler breaks down, the first question is usually whether it is time for a new one. We fix boilers and we fit boilers, so here is how we would decide for our own homes.

Repair is usually right when

  • The boiler is under 10 years old
  • It has been serviced regularly
  • The part is available and the repair is a small share of the cost of a new boiler
  • It has not broken down several times in the last year

Many faults, such as a diverter valve, a fan, a pump or a pressure sensor, are routine repairs that give the boiler years more life.

Replacement is worth considering when

  • The boiler is over 12 to 15 years old and breaking down more often
  • Parts for your model are discontinued or very expensive
  • The heat exchanger has failed, which is often one of the most expensive repairs
  • Your household has changed, for example an extra bathroom or a loft conversion, and the boiler no longer keeps up

The numbers we will give you

On a repair visit we tell you what is wrong, what the repair costs, and whether we think it is good value. If a new boiler makes more sense, we explain why and give you a free written quote. We never push a replacement on a repair call, and the decision is always yours.

Before you call

Check the basics: is the pressure between 1 and 1.5 bar, is the gas on at the meter, and is the thermostat calling for heat? Our guide to repressurising a combi boiler covers the most common fix. If that does not sort it, book a boiler repair.

Stuck? Call Lee.

If you are not sure it is safe, stop and call. Advice by phone is free.

020 8050 5913

Related services

  • Boiler repair

    Same-day fault finding and repairs on gas, LPG and oil boilers.

  • Boiler installation

    High-efficiency condensing boilers, fitted neatly, with up to 15 years warranty on boilers.

  • Boiler servicing

    Fixed-price annual service for gas and oil boilers to keep them safe and under warranty.

Our work on these jobs

See the gallery
  • Green PHS engineer working inside an open combi boiler casing
  • Engineer testing the wiring on a boiler control board
  • Inside a gas boiler during a repair, showing the heat exchanger and pipework
  • Newly installed white Vaillant combi boiler on a teal wall

Photographs of jobs completed by Green PHS engineers.

More advice

Call Lee. He picks up.

Tell him what is happening. If it is a quick fix, he will talk you through it for free. If not, we will get an engineer to you, usually the same day.

Call Lee Get a quote